Extra Virgin vs Pressato vs Infused Olive Oil: Which Should You Choose?

Extra Virgin vs Pressato vs Infused Olive Oil: Which Should You Choose?

November 8, 2026Christina Lier

Start with the flavor you want, then decide when to add it. Unflavored extra virgin olive oil brings olive character; pressato and infused oils add another flavor. For cooking and finishing, that distinction is more useful than treating the three names as a ranking.

Choose by the flavor you want to taste

Extra virgin olive oil is the starting point when you want the olives themselves to provide the flavor. A grassy, peppery oil brings a different character than a mild, fruity one. That distinction can matter more to your finished dish than whether you added the oil during cooking or afterward.

Extra virgin describes an oil grade, while pressato and infused describe ways of introducing additional flavors. They are not three equivalent quality grades.

Pressato commonly describes milling olives with an ingredient such as citrus; infusion adds flavor after the oil is produced. Neither method alone tells you how intense the oil will taste or makes one automatically better than the other. Product descriptions should identify the ingredients and method used for the particular bottle.

Decide whether the oil is a base or an accent

For sautéed vegetables or a tray of roasted potatoes, choose unflavored extra virgin oil when you want the seasoning to come from the other ingredients. Choose a complementary flavored oil suitable for cooking when you want that flavor throughout the dish.

For a more noticeable aromatic accent, add the flavored oil after cooking instead. Heat can soften distinctive aromas. You can also split the job: cook with unflavored extra virgin oil, then finish with a small amount of pressato or infused oil. This lets you adjust the final flavor without adding more oil to the pan.

The practical difference is control. Oil added before cooking coats the food and becomes part of the cooking step. Oil added just before serving lets you taste and adjust the accent on the finished plate. Start with a light drizzle rather than committing the whole dish to a strong flavor.

Let the dressing ingredients guide your choice

If you are adding fresh citrus, herbs, and mustard, unflavored oil lets those ingredients lead. A flavored oil can supply one of those notes instead. Taste before adding more seasoning so the flavors do not compete.

For example, if you want a citrus note without adding more citrus juice, a citrus-flavored oil can contribute aroma while you adjust the dressing’s acidity separately. It does not replace the acidic ingredient; it gives you another way to balance flavor.

Choose the flavor first, the method second

If you are deciding between two similarly flavored bottles, “pressato” versus “infused” is useful production information, not a verdict on which will suit your food better. Compare the stated ingredients and flavor descriptions. When tasting is possible, choose the one you prefer.

You do not need a different bottle for every cooking method. Start with an unflavored extra virgin oil you enjoy, then add a flavored oil for an accent you actually want to use. For a specialty oil, follow the producer’s cooking guidance rather than assuming its flavoring method determines heat suitability.

For specific dishes and pairings, see How to Use Flavored Olive Oil and Balsamic Vinegar: 10 Easy Ideas.

More articles